Sunday, 19 May 2019

DETECTIVE PIKACHU REVIEW: Is it very affective?


Pokémon has finally broken into live action… but does Detective Pikachu evolve the franchise to new levels, or simply hit us with confusion.


Pokémon is a generational multi-billion media monster. Starting out as a gaming phenomenon, Pokémon has amassed a globally fierce fanbase spanning anime, cards, toys and of course movies. For generations fans have been craving a jump to live action adventures and the wait is finally over…

Pikachu is here… but not how most of us would suspect. The undisputed cuddly king of the pocket monsters, Pikachu, is known for his sparky charm and plucky attitude. Detective Pikachu however, is a coffee guzzling, wise cracking wreck that literally asks you to smell his finger. Voiced by the charismatically cool Ryan Reynolds, Detective Pikachu is shockingly sincere and infectiously irreverent in live action. Reynolds manages to deliver another memorable characterisation that surprisingly doesn’t simply wreak of diluted Deadpool (Shock!). Pikachu brings extra zing to a previously one-dimensional cutesy character and boy is he cute. There are distinctly memorable moments delivered by Reynolds. I genuinely laughed out loud and left wanting more witty wise cracks and less Pika-Pika in possible future instalments. Detective Pikachu… I choose you! 

Reynolds is the undisputed fuzzy frontrunner of this brand-new franchise. Taking Pokémon beyond serious to a place of sophisticated silliness. The first act brilliantly sets up the weird world of Pokémon and pokes fun at the obvious cartoonish catching of cute monsters for the sake of battling. This movie however, focuses less on the usual master quest and more on the inclusive world of humans and Pokémon alike. Instead of Ash Ketchum we get Tim Goodman, portrayed by the competent Justice Smith. The human buddy to Reynolds’ Detective Pikachu breathes fresh life into the franchise and shows how hard being a Pokémon trainer actually could be. Smith is relatable and offers an understated performance that brings reality to this unique universe.


Indie actress Kathryn Newton also joins Smith and adds quirk alongside her Psyducks endearing quack. Newton plays reporter Lucy Stevens and feels straight out of Anime. Her kawaii-cool aesthetic and nose for a story adds a little extra camp to the trio of mainly man-child humour. 
The additional cast are distinctly less desirable. Rita Ora is woefully wooden and adds nothing to the story other than a soundtrack opportunity. Ora’s character repels charisma and used sleep very affectively. Snooze! Bill Nighy and Ken Watanabe also fair less favourably. Both great additions to the story but are atrociously underused and suffer from poor script support. They just about manage to get away safely with their natural onscreen charm but I wanted more.  


The true Joy of Detective Pikachu rightly remains with the Pokémon. You are treated to a plethora of real life Poké-pals. All used with expert eccentricity (talking about you Mr. Mime.) The screen is literally filled with your favourite characters and creates an alluring re-watch-ability to see Pokémon interact with a world we know and love. The world building is truly incredible and feels evolved from the animated alternative. The city scenes feel reminiscent of Jordan Cronenworth’s Blade Runner cinematography with a Japanese infusion. Similarly, the cinematography in Detective Pikachu offers real world depth and dimension that complements the extraverted Pokémon aesthetic. Cinematographer John Mathieson chooses to shoot on traditional film and offers an organic view of a fantastic fantasy. Great work John!




Director, Rob Lettmerman definitely had the superior elements that could of created a superb secret sauce. However, the last act sadly fails to fully impress. With an engaging homage to Roger Rabbit, the first act buddies up our stars perfectly. The world of Pokémon is established and the action builds but sadly never reaches crescendo. Letterman is clearly more Pokémon breeder than master and his use of action simply isn’t very effective.  Maybe next time?

To conclude, Detective Pikachu is a cheeky turn on the serious fan series. Reynolds shocks as a witty Pikachu and is brilliant when creating the classic buddy-up dynamic with Smith and the wider world around him. You’ll definitely laugh, maybe cry and enjoy the odd, somewhat obvious, twisty moment. But the real joy comes from Poké-spotting and reminiscing about your favourites from generations gone by. Detective Pikachu definitely wins the battle with charm but has someway to go before becoming a true Pokémon master… until next time.

Catch Detective Pikachu
 in theatres now!



Popular